Broadway

Aisle Say on the Square: The Future is What it Used to Be

Aisle Say on the Square: The Future is What it Used to Be
Reed Birney, Tom Sturridge, Olivia Wilde

Reed Birney, Tom Sturridge, Olivia Wilde Photo Credit: Julieta Cervantes

When a theatrical work is presented with honesty and integrity and a high level of craftsmanship, quite often I find that the notion of whether or not the critic actually likes it is beside the point. I go back to an article written over 30 years by Stephen King, in which he wrote: “My favorite crime novelist—often imitated but never duplicated—is Jim Thompson. Thompson was rarely reviewed, but when he was he was excoriated. I was in fact originally attracted to him by a review that called Cropper’s Cabin ‘unbearably repulsive.’ I immediately wanted to read that book, figuring anyone with enough energy to get a reviewer to call his work unbearably repulsive must have something going for him.”

In an odd way, the new stage adaptation of George Orwell’s dystopian novel 1984 falls into that category, by co-dramatist/directors Robert Icke and Duncan Macmillan. How or if you take to it depends on how you respond to an agit-prop warning whose constant undercurrent is the kind of tension one associates with the proverbial fluorescent bulbs over the solitary cage, that constantly buzz and never get turned off.
The totalitarian society it dramatizes is, as in the novel, one which is pervasive, systematically reductionist, relentless about reprogramming individuality and has eyes everywhere. Except maybe that small, private, disused back room no one ever knows about. You hope.
And, as in the book, it tells the story of Winston Smith (Tom Sturridge), who sees but doesn’t say, and the romance he has with the rebel Julia (Olivia Wilde), who seduces his kindred spirit with her kindled spiritedness; and his encounters with O’Brien (Reed Birney), who represents the governing body symbolized by the all-wise, perfect leader, Big Brother.
To describe too much of what goes on is perhaps to spoil the experience, which, though “limited” to the proscenium stage, has an environmental effect, because of the sound design (Tom Gibbons) and approach to the visual (scenic and costumer design: Chloe Lamford, lighting design: Natasha Chivers) that puts danger in familiar settings, puts distance between the audience and scenes of hope; and eventually deconstructs the universe, so it’s as if he have entered the propagandist screens we only observed before. The aural-visual dynamic goes from silent to explosive, stable to shattered.
Almost necessarily, the casting is almost irrelevant, save for one role, because even Winston, in his quest to be an individual, is a symbol. Denied access to subversive material, he has no verbal wit, no specific aspiration other than freedom of thought, he has to be an everyman; and Julia, similarly, can’t be much more than a symbol of one who represents freedom of physicality. This is not to say that the actors needn’t be talented and in sync with the tone, but any sufficiently watchable couple would do.
Tom Sturridge, Reed Birney

Tom Sturridge, Reed Birney Photo Credit: Julieta Cervantes

The actor for whom, 1984 is a showcase is of course the villain. And sure enough, Reed Birney makes a meal out of it. Birney’s voice isn’t very deep, his physical presence isn’t very menacing—ironically, he’s kitted out to a symbol too: an executive in a suit, one of those behind-the-scenes power brokers we always talk about and always feel powerless to influence. But because he’s the phantom made manifest, he’s the one who isn’t generic, because he has the freedom to fill out his trope. He gets to bend the rules, enforce the rules, make up the rules. He is both the party line and the random factor. And as always, when your leads lack idiosyncrasy, the villain has the best lines. Birney never overplays his hand, but he never has to. His character owns the room. And everybody in it.

In a perverse way, the casting of O’Brien is almost irrelevant too, but that’s because there’s no limit to the ways you can play him. You could swap in Ned Beatty, from Network. Same guy. Or Hal Holbrook from All the President’s Men. Same guy. Or any fine actor who ever played Dickinson in 1776. Same guy. He just has to be the formidable contrast.
But what this all adds up to for you depends on where it hits you. Will you find being immersed in its totalitarian mercilessness invigorating? Prescient? Relevant? Or obvious and fatiguing? I know people from both camps. And I fall into both. In the end, I can only suggest taking your cue from Mr. King: Any production with enough energy to provoke such diversity of reaction is probably worth a visit.

Broadway

David Spencer is an award-winning composer-lyricist, lyricist-librettist, author and musical theatre teacher. He has written music and lyrics for the Richard Rodgers Development Award-winning musical The Fabulist, which also contributed to his winning a Kleban lyrics award and several Gilman & Gonzalez-Falla Theatre Foundation grants. He is also lyricist-librettist for two musicals with composer Alan Menken: Weird Romance (WPA 1992, York 2004) and The Apprenticeship of Duddy Kravitz, which had its sold out, extended world premiere in Montreal in Summer 2015; cast album release soon. He made his professional debut in 1984 with the English Adaptation of La Bohéme at the Public Theatre; and he has since written music and lyrics for Theatreworks/USA’s all-new, award-winning Young Audience versions of The Phantom of the Opera (1996) and Les Misérables (1999) (book and direction for both by Rob Barron). Currently he is writing book, music and lyrics for a musical based on the iconic Russian novel The Golden Calf. Spencer’s published books are the Alien Nation novel Passing Fancy (Pocket, 1994), The Musical Theatre Writer’s Survival Guide (Heinemann, 2005, a regularly reprinted industry standard) and the script of Weird Romance (Samuel French, 1993). He is on faculty and teaches at the BMI-Lehman Engel Musical Theatre Workshop and has taught at HB Studio, the Workshop Studio Theater and Goldsmith’s College in London. His primary professional affiliations are BMI, The Dramatists Guild and The International Association of Media Tie-in Writers.

More in Broadway

Wicked

Wicked: A Green Witch Can Be A Good Witch, Hazel

RossSeptember 21, 2017
Betsy Wolfe

Carousel Loses Cast Member Betsy Wolfe

Suzanna BowlingSeptember 19, 2017
Mandy Gonzalez, Lin Manuel Miranda

Viva Broadway! Brought Out Lin Manuel Miranda, His Dad and More

Genevieve Rafter KeddySeptember 16, 2017
Michael Moore

Aisle Say on the Square: One Could Do Moore With Less

David SpencerSeptember 15, 2017
Hal Prince

Aisle Say on the Square: Prince Charming

David SpencerSeptember 15, 2017
Bernedette Peters

The Broadway Flea Market & Grand Auction Brings Bernadette Peters and Broadway’s Best Front and Center

Suzanna BowlingSeptember 15, 2017
Lin Manuel Miranda

Viva Broadway Lin-Manuel Miranda and John Leguizamo in Times Square Together

Suzanna BowlingSeptember 15, 2017
Patti LuPone

Patti LuPone: Don’t Monkey With Broadway

Suzanna BowlingSeptember 13, 2017
Zainab Jah

Tony Winner Rebecca Taichman Directs Zainab Jah in School Girls; Or, the African Mean Girls Play

Suzanna BowlingSeptember 13, 2017