MvVO Art Launches AD ART SHOW
Broadway

M Butterfly Where Relationships Are The Fantasy

M Butterfly Where Relationships Are The Fantasy
Clive Owen, Jin Ha

Clive Owen, Jin Ha Photo by Matthew Murphy

The revival of David Henry Hwang’s M. Butterfly at the Cort Theatre lacks chemistry and plausibility. Having never seen the 1988 Tony Award-winning best play, I was excited to finally experience this true-life story. Loosely based on real-life events, with this cast, it is hard to believe any of this ever happened. For those who do not know the story, opera lover and Frenchman Rene Gallimard (Clive Owen with a British accent) has long been infatuated with Puccini’s Madame Butterfly and the title character Cho-Cho-San. We first meet Gallimard in prison, as he tells his story. It began when Gallimard becomes a diplomat in China. Gallimard, a sexually repressed male is uncomfortable around women, so he marries a woman older than him for political reasons, but there is no love there. When he hears Song, a male Peking opera singer (Jin Ha), he begins an on-off 20-year affair. The problem is Gallimard believes that Song is female and an innocent, when in reality, he is male and a spy for the Chinese government.

Jin Ha

Jin Ha Photo by Matthew Murphy

In order for this relationship to work, there must be chemistry between Gallimard and Song. In this production, there is not. I never believed that either was infatuated enough or in lust enough to make this story real. You also must believe that Song can pass as female and sadly I never believed that. Mr. Ha always seemed masculine to me, even when he was dressed to the nines. Gallimard must be conflicted, passionate, a delusional romantic, who is tortured enough to believe so strongly that Song can actually become pregnant. Clive Owens performance is lacking in any kind of substance. At times, it felt like he was reading the phone book. When the pregnancy is announced, I was actually shocked that Gallimard was stupid enough to believe this statement, especially in the scene where it happens. In the end, Gallimard’s response seems almost laughable, despite the tragedy, again due to a disbelief of the amount of grief that had to have resided within him.

Jin Ha

Jin Ha Photo by Matthew Murphy

Even the East/West conflict is glossed over here, except for Julie Taymor and set designer Paul Steinberg’s clunky sliding panels.

The script has been revised, but I actually would have liked to have read the original, as I found myself feeling nothing for Gallimard and the deception played on him. I don’t even know if you can call it deception because it seemed more of an inability to not want to see the blatant truth. Gallimard comes off as a closet homosexual, who is forever stuck. In reading the true story, this definitely was not the case.

Taymor’s direction is heavy on the spectacle of the opera with lots of dancing, choreographed by Ma Cong, but if you have seen Chinese Opera even that wasn’t represented well.

This revival of M. Butterfly just lacks humanity and all those things that make us feel and are human.

Broadway

Suzanna, co-owns and publishes the newspaper Times Square Chronicles or T2C. At one point a working actress, she has performed in numerous productions in film, TV, cabaret and theatre. She has performed at The New Orleans Jazz festival, The United Nations and Carnegie Hall. Currently she has a screenplay in the works, which she developed with her mentor and friend the late Arthur Herzog. She was the Broadway Informer on the all access cable TV Show “The New Yorkers,” soon to be “The Tourist Channel.” email: suzanna@t2conline.com

More in Broadway

My View: Barrington Stage Co. Announces $125,000 Raised For New Works Initiative at New York City Benefit

Stephen SorokoffNovember 16, 2017

My View: Maltby & Shire & Jamie deRoy at The Friars Club

Stephen SorokoffNovember 15, 2017
Betty Corwin, Patrick Hoffman

The League of Professional Theatre Women Presented Betty Corwin With a Special Lifetime Achievement Award Right Before She Turns 97

Magda KatzNovember 10, 2017
The Band's Visit

He Says: The Band’s Glorious (Re) Visit to Bet Haatikva and My Heart

RossNovember 10, 2017
The Band's Visit

She Say’s: The Band’s Visit Is Still Hallmark Card To Life

Suzanna BowlingNovember 10, 2017
Bee Gee's musical

Universal To Develop Musical Based on the Life Story and Music of the Bee Gees

Suzanna BowlingNovember 9, 2017
Daryl Roth, Linda Weiner

Daryl Roth and Linda Winer In Conversation Part 2

Suzanna BowlingNovember 9, 2017
School of Rock

Broadway Under the Stars at The Shops at Columbus Circle Begins November 13th

Suzanna BowlingNovember 8, 2017
Ramin Karimloo

Inside the Show: Inside Make Believe on Broadway Gala, Honoring Josh Groban!

Genevieve Rafter KeddyNovember 7, 2017