Off Broadway

A Sweet Revival of Carmelina at Musical in Mufti

A Sweet Revival of Carmelina at Musical in Mufti
Andréa Burns

Anne L. Nathan, Andréa Burns,Timothy John Smith Photocredit: Ben Strothmann.

Carmelina is a musical with a book by Joseph Stein and Alan Jay Lerner, lyrics by Lerner, and music by Burton Lane. Based on the 1968 film Buona Sera, Mrs. Campbell (which also inspired the book for Mamma Mia!), the show had eleven on Broadway production, and opened on April 8, 1979 at the St. James Theatre, where it ran for only seventeen performances. A nomination for Best Original Score was its sole recognition.

Anne L. Nathan

Anne L. Nathan Photocredit: Ben Strothmann

In the show Camelina “Campbell” (Andrea Burns) is an Italian woman has spurns the constant advances of local café owner Vittorio (Joey Sorge) because her heart still belongs to the man she tragically lost. In reality, she had affairs with three different GIs and has no idea who fathered the girl. During the American occupation of Italy – slept with three American GIs in the course of a month, Cpl. Karzinski (Timothy John Smith), Lt. Smith (Jim Stanek), and Sgt. Walter Braddock (Evan Harrington). By the time she discovers she is pregnant, all three have moved on, and she, has convinced all  three (who are unaware of the existence of the other two) to support “his” daughter Gia financially.

Jim Stanek, Timothy John Smith, Evan Harrington

Jim Stanek, Timothy John Smith, Evan Harrington Photocredit: Ben Strothmann

To protect her reputation, as well as the reputation of her unborn child, Camelina has raised the girl to believe her mother is the widow of an army air force captain named Eddie Campbell, a name she borrowed from a can of soup (she is very fond of Campbell’s soups).

Jim Stanek, Evan Harrington, Anne L. Nathan, Joey Sorge, Andréa Burns, Timothy John Smith , Antonio Cipriano, MaryJoanna Grisso

Jim Stanek, Evan Harrington, Anne L. Nathan, Joey Sorge, Andréa Burns, Timothy John Smith , Antonio Cipriano, MaryJoanna Grisso Photo credit: Ben Strothmann

After the end of World War II in the village of San Forino, where the three ex-airmen attend a unit-wide reunion of the 293rd Squadron of the 15th AF in the village where they were stationed. Carla is forced into a series of comic situations as she tries to keep them – each one anxious to meet his daughter (MaryJoanna Grisso) for the first time.

Andréa Burns, Timothy John Smith , Antonio Cipriano

Andréa Burns, Timothy John Smith , Antonio Cipriano Photocredit: Ben Strothmann

When confronted, Mrs. Campbell admits to her Cook (Anne L. Nathan) she does not know which of the three men is Gia’s father. She challenges the men by asking them what kind of father each would have been, particularly because they have never been there for all the small but important life events of their daughter. Provoked by this, the potential fathers talk to Gia and insist that she cannot run off with the young man who loves her (Antonio Cipriano). The “fathers” cease the support.

The cast is superbly cast, with the fathers getting the best numbers. The show is extremely ballad heavy.

The York and its company give this show a winning revival in their Mufti series. Musical Director David Hancock Turner, makes the score sound lush and Director Michael Leeds, keeps the cast on its toes. Audiences of an older generation will find this show charming, while the younger generation will find this show overtly sweet.

Bravo to The York for giving shows another look.

Carmelina: Musicals in Mufti: The York Theatre, until

Off Broadway

Suzanna, co-owns and publishes the newspaper Times Square Chronicles or T2C. At one point a working actress, she has performed in numerous productions in film, TV, cabaret, opera and theatre. She has performed at The New Orleans Jazz festival, The United Nations and Carnegie Hall. She has a screenplay and a TV show in the works, which she developed with her mentor and friend the late Arthur Herzog. She is a proud member of the Drama Desk and the Outer Critics Circle and was a nominator. Email:

More in Off Broadway

Donna Lynne Champlin, Marc Kudisch, Mary Testa and More Star In It’s a Wonderful Life

Suzanna BowlingDecember 6, 2022

Theatre News: Moulin Rouge!, The Great Gatsby, Lillias White, KPOP, The Wiz and Ain’t No Mo

Suzanna BowlingDecember 2, 2022

A Fond Farewell To Irene Cara

Suzanna BowlingNovember 27, 2022

Off Broadway League Announces 2022 Holiday Toy Drive

Suzanna BowlingNovember 23, 2022

The Mint Theatre Unearths Noel Coward’s The Rat Trap

Suzanna BowlingNovember 22, 2022

A Man of No Importance Comes Out Beautiful and Strong

RossNovember 21, 2022

Catch as Catch Can An Actor’s Showcase

Suzanna BowlingNovember 21, 2022

The York Theatre Celebrated With the 30th Oscar Hammerstein Award Gala

Genevieve Rafter KeddyNovember 20, 2022

Music and CD News: Funny Girl, Between the Lines, Matilda The Musical, Love in Hate Nation, Darling Grenadine, Sondheim Unplugged: The NYC Sessions – Volume Three, Edmund Bagnell and Concord Theatricals Recordings

Suzanna BowlingNovember 19, 2022