MvVO Art Launches AD ART SHOW
Off Broadway

An Enchanted April, Not So Enchanting

An Enchanted April, Not So Enchanting

Aaron Phillips, Christiana Cole Photo by Carol Rosegg

Utah Lyric Opera, in association with Thunder Media Group, opened their New York Premiere of An Enchanted April, a new musical based on the novel The Enchanted April, by Elizabeth von Arnim, with book and lyrics by Elizabeth Hansen, music & lyrics by C. Michael Perry and directed by Alice Jankell last night at Theatre Row, 410 West 42nd Street.

Leah Hocking, Gena Sims, Alma Cuervo Photo by Carol Rosegg

An Enchanted April begins in London, when at a ladies club Lotty (Leah Hocking) reads in a newspaper advertisement about San Salvatore, a Tuscan villa. She convinces Rose (Christiana Cole) that she sees her there. Lotty feels trapped in her marriage to Mellersh (Jim Stanek). Rose and Frederick’s (Aaron Phillips) marriage is also failing. They decide to rent the villa and go away on holiday, but it is too expensive, so they advertise for house mates. Lady Caroline (Gena Sims), an acquaintance of Frederick’s isn’t in love with her fiancé and Mrs. Fisher (Alma Cuervo), a rich widow is financially well off. Both apply and now the four are set. Renting the villa means references, but the time is 1922. Rose appeals to the villa’s owner Briggs (Peter Reid Lambert). He falls in love with her thinking Rose to be a war widow.

Aaron Phillips, Christiana Cole, Leah Hocking, Jim Stanek, Alma Cuervo, Gena Sims Photo by Carol Rosegg

At the villa, Francesca (Melody Meeks Putnam), the maid, curses under her breath in Italian at these women, who have come to Italy to find themselves and they do. Lotty who feels unloved and under appreciated by her husband Mellersh, but she misses him and invites him to join. He ends up meeting Lady Caroline and Mrs. Fisher and sees Lotty’s value. He learns to show Lotty his love for her, which was buried all this time.

Jim Stanek, Alma Cuervo Photo by Carol Rosegg

Rose and Frederick, lost a child and the guilt has left the marriage empty. Both turned away from each other. Lady Caroline, was a nurse and the hours of war have left her bereft and Ms. Fisher feels that life has past her by. In the end, all got what they came for during one Enchanted April.

Jim Stanek, Leah Hocking Photo by Carol Rosegg

The score is messy, underworked and banal. The lyrics don’t always hit the mark. At the end of Act 1, we get what sounds like a snippet from Into The Woods, sadly it is “Agony”. The end of the show has the run of “Sunday” from Sunday in The Park With George.

The good news is for the most part An Enchanted April, is sung extremely well and is handled competently by musical director Richard Daley, though who’s idea to use the a synthesizer was jarring. Mr Daley is really a wonderful musical on his own.

Christiana Cole, Jim Stanek, Peter Reid Lambert and Aaron Phillips have exquisite voices, especially Mr. Phillips. Ms. Hocking grows on you and will touch your heart with her comedic and heartbreaking performance. Alma Cuervo’s “This Feeling”, shows the audience what I have known since Quilters, just how this women can interpret a song. Ms. Putnam, is rather hysterical as the maid. Who fails here is Gena Sims, who’s singing just isn’t up to par.

Alice Jankell’s direction is too much for the space. William Armstrong’s sets is not clever enough and the lighting doesn’t add just how magnificent San Salvatore is, nor the time of day. Matthew Solomon’s costumes are a mesh of era’s.

An Enchanted April isn’t horrible, it just isn’t good despite the talent on stage. The musical, made me want to see the movie, as the storyline is touching and the end of this over two hour long show felt rushed.

An Enchanted April: Utah Lyric Opera, in association with Thunder Media Group at Theatre Row, 410 West 42nd St., until Nov. 16th.

Off Broadway

Suzanna, co-owns and publishes the newspaper Times Square Chronicles or T2C. At one point a working actress, she has performed in numerous productions in film, TV, cabaret, opera and theatre. She has performed at The New Orleans Jazz festival, The United Nations and Carnegie Hall. She has a screenplay and a TV show in the works, which she developed with her mentor and friend the late Arthur Herzog. She is a proud member of the Drama Desk and the Outer Critics Circle and was a nominator. Email: suzanna@t2conline.com

More in Off Broadway

Inside The Outer Critics Circle Awards

Suzanna BowlingMay 28, 2022

Theatre News: Angela Lansbury, The Karate Kid, Lempicka, Girl From North Country, Cathy Maguire and Night Of AThousand Judys

Suzanna BowlingMay 25, 2022

Fraver by Design

Lawrence HarbisonMay 23, 2022

The Drama League Awards and You Are There

Genevieve Rafter KeddyMay 21, 2022

The 88th Annual Drama League Awards Winners

Genevieve Rafter KeddyMay 21, 2022

Inside Rehearsals for The Orchard Featuring Jessica Hecht, Mikhail Baryshnikov & More

Genevieve Rafter KeddyMay 20, 2022

Theatre News: Naked Theatre, HYPROV:Improv Under Hypnosis, Oratorio for Living Things, The Shubert Foundation’s 2022 High School Theatre Festival and Are You There?

Suzanna BowlingMay 20, 2022

Theatre News: Parade, Tony Awards, Amas Musical Theatre, Vineyard Theatre, Fountain of You and A Burning Church

Suzanna BowlingMay 18, 2022

The 2021-2022 Outer Critics Circle Award Winners

Suzanna BowlingMay 17, 2022