Oklahoma Is More Of An Overcast Day

Oklahoma Is More Of An Overcast Day

“Country a-changing”, got to change with it!” Curly to Laurey. 

There is a lot to admire and a lot to ponder with Daniel Fish’s production of Rodgers and Hammerstein’s groundbreaking 1943 musical “Oklahoma!” Deconstructed, the lyric’s pack powerful punches; however, they are not always sung well.

Ali Stoker, James Davis, Patrick Vailll Photo by Teddy Wolff.

I don’t mind shows going against the grain – I actually find that exciting and innovative – but there are key elements that should be adhered to. I expect the singers to sing well, the actors to emotionally move me, the dancing to bring the show to the next level, and consistency in the time frame of where this is taking place. If the text is taking away from that, then the text needs to change.

Patrick Vaill, Will Brill, Photo by Teddy Wolff.

Oklahoma became a state in 1907. They did not have crock pots, boxes of Jiffy cornbread, plastic containers, or mikes. In the title song, the lyrics state “Brand new state, Brand new state, gonna treat you great!”. As I entered the theatre, I was confused as to the era due to Laura Jellinek’s set design. Could I be in a warped timeline? I can buy that.

Damon Duanno, Mary Testa Photo by Teddy Wolff

As the charming cowboy, Curly McLain (Damon Duanno), sings with guitar in hand, I appreciated the stripped-down orchestrations by Daniel Kluger. Duanno almost immediately wins us over with his heart-on-his-sleeve approach. He has an organic appeal.

The seven-piece bluegrass string band plays Richard Rodgers’ iconic score with a country twang, which is a new way of hearing this, but it works.

Rebecca Naomi Jones Photo by Teddy Wolff

As Aunt Eller (Mary Testa) and her niece, Laurey Williams (Rebecca Naomi Jones), enter, suddenly musicality goes out the window. I am a huge fan of Ms. Testa, but she has been directed to sing this lyrical score stridently and it does not work, especially later on in “Out of My Dreams”. She still has that same fabulous deadpan approach, which makes her right for the role. Ms. Naomi Jones seriously cannot sing this score. I have seen her in other productions, and she can sing, so what happened? I blame both mishaps on the musical director, Nathan Koci. Mr. Fish has also directed Ms. Naomi Jones as incredibly sulky; she is almost disengaged with quiet indifference. Thankfully, when she interacts with Curley there is a wonderful longing that comes out. Her interactions with Jud just seem to push the boundaries.

As the comedic relief, Ado Annie Carnes (Ali Stroker), whose “Can’t Say No” is a delight. She makes us see the woman in the prime of knowing her control on men. Her interaction with the Persian salesman, Ali Hakam (Will Brill), and cowboy Will Parker (James Davis) are all believable and sexy. All three of these characters sing well. I especially appreciated the song “It’s a Scandal! It’s a Outrage!” being added back in. Mr. Brill is definitely a find with his impeccable timing. Mr. Davis makes us get his longing for Ado Annie, but his big dance number, “Kansas City”, is reduced to clumsy jumping around on tables.

Mallory Portnoy, Patrick Vaill Photo by Teddy Wolff

The scene between Curley and Jud is done in the dark, in semi-monotone voices, until a videographer shines Jud’s face up on the screen. The last motif leads us to think the reason these two men fight is possibly because they long for each other.

Lighting director Scott Zielinski has done some rather cool things with the lighting. I loved the green haze for when we are in the actor’s heads.

Then there is the ballet. Gabrielle Hamilton is a strong, beautiful modern dancer and if she were in a modern dance performance, I could understand John Higinbotham’s choreography, but this piece is way too long and when compared to Agnus De Mille, this ballet seems more like a nightmare.

In watching this show, I was reminded of David Cromer’s Our Townand thought if you were going to update this, why not do everything modern and then in the ballet, show us the past and really get into the issues of political incorrectness?

What the most confusing part is, is the ending. What I think was supposed to shine a light on white male privilege and gun violence fails for several reasons. Jud is white, he has tried to kill Curley more than once and has threatened Laurey with what seems like a death threat. He was never invited to the wedding yet shows up and gives Curley, who sold his horse and his gun, another gun. Then he steps towards him and Curley shoots him. Somehow, we are supposed to feel sorry for him. Do you feel sorry when a killer or a sociopath is killed? In the original piece, it is alluded that Jud burnt down and killed the girl at the last place he worked at. If this was said during this version, I missed that. In leaving the theatre, the only thing audiences were talking about was how did that much blood get on our two stars.

Photo Credit: Teddy Wolff.
Photo by Teddy Wolff.

There were a handful of audience members who left at intermission, but hey, they did that after the first killing in Sweeny Todd. I will say I did love the complimentary chili and cornbread.

Oklahoma!: Circle In the Square, 1633 Broadway 


Suzanna, co-owns and publishes the newspaper Times Square Chronicles or T2C. At one point a working actress, she has performed in numerous productions in film, TV, cabaret, opera and theatre. She has performed at The New Orleans Jazz festival, The United Nations and Carnegie Hall. She has a screenplay and a TV show in the works, which she developed with her mentor and friend the late Arthur Herzog. She is a proud member of the Drama Desk and the Outer Critics Circle and was a nominator. Email:

More in Broadway

The New Broadway Musical Shucked Finds Its Cast

Suzanna BowlingJanuary 30, 2023

MTC’s The Collaboration Makes Disposable Sellable Art for Consumption

RossJanuary 28, 2023

Roundabout Now Accepting Applications: Directing Fellowship and Directors Group

Suzanna BowlingJanuary 28, 2023

Stephen Adly Guirgis’ Between Riverside and Crazy Has Much To Say About Connection

Suzanna BowlingJanuary 26, 2023

Will Swenson and The Cast of A Beautiful Noise, The Neil Diamond Musical Wished The Musical Icon Happy Birthday

Suzanna BowlingJanuary 26, 2023

The Outer Critics Circle Announces Dates and New Category Distinctions for the 72nd Annual Outer Critics Circle Awards

Suzanna BowlingJanuary 25, 2023
Adrienne Warren

Theatre News: Room, Camelot, Between Riverside and Crazy, Bedlam and Hip Hop Cinderella

Suzanna BowlingJanuary 24, 2023

Kimberly Akimbo Will Take Over Wollman Rink To Celebrate Original Broadway Cast Recording

Suzanna BowlingJanuary 24, 2023

Theatre News: Lady Day At Emerson’s Bar & Grill, Porgy & Bess, Days Of Wine and Roses and Funny Girl

Suzanna BowlingJanuary 22, 2023