Connect with us

Off Broadway

The Giant Hoax A Delightful Children’s Show With a Message

Published

on

Staci Stout Photo by Brian E. Long

The Cardiff Giant was one of the most famous hoaxes in American history. It was a 10-foot-tall (3.0 m) purported “petrifiedman” uncovered on October 16, 1869, by workers digging a well behind the barn of William C. “Stub” Newell in Cardiff, New York. Both Newell’s and an unauthorized copy made by P. T. Barnum are still being displayed. The original is currently on display at The Farmers’ Museum in Cooperstown, New York.

Staci Stout. Forest VanDyke and the cast of The Giant Hoax Photo by Brian E. Long

Kit Goldstein Grant’s new musical The Giant Hoax based on this story, opened tonight on Theatre Row, featuring the adorable Staci Stout as our heroine, Emily.

Robyne Parrish, Staci Stout Photo by Brian E. Long

Ms. Stout will remind you of a young Bernadette Peters, with her plucky performance. Emily is bright with an active imagination, who has run away from home only to find herself in the employ of showman, William “Stub” Newell (a winning Forest VanDyke), the owner of a petrified, prehistoric giant. Stub and Emily take a liking to each other because both believe in tall tales and the giant.

Forest VanDyke and the cast of The Giant Hoax Photo by Brian E. Long

When the giant comes to life courtesy of (a delightful Daniel Moser) and Puppeteers (Mary Albert and Jianzi Colon-Soto) he becomes the lonely Emily’s imaginary friend. We also meet Emily’s mother (Robyne Parrish), through her dreams. Emily has run away wanting an adventure and to no longer be a burden. Stub’s teaches Emily salesmanship and how to tell even taller tales. When P.T. Barnum (Paul Aguirre) threatens Stub’s business with a giant of his own, Emily has to sort through what is fact, or imagination and is telling the truth tattletaling? In doing so Emily grows up, but loses a piece of her innocents, but not her heart.

In the end there is a sucker is born every minuet, as Stubs confesses to the hoax and charges not just 50 cents, but a dollar to see the hoax. And this my friends happened.

Christopher Michaels’ directing was straight forward and Molly Model’s choreography infectious. The music direction by Jonathon Lynch gave an even sound, that filled the theatre.

Goldstein Grant book, music, and lyrics captures the time period and brings about a delightful children’s musical that doesn’t talk down. My one critique would be the canned score did not help bring out the orchestrations by Mark Brymer, made the music sound a little flat.

The Giant Hoax is the first main stage production for IndieWorks Theatre Company and I look forward to seeing more of what they produce.

The Giant Hoax is presented by IndieWorks Theatre Company in association with Visceral Entertainment on Theater Row, 410 West 42 St. until Dec. 7th.

Suzanna, co-owns and publishes the newspaper Times Square Chronicles or T2C. At one point a working actress, she has performed in numerous productions in film, TV, cabaret, opera and theatre. She has performed at The New Orleans Jazz festival, The United Nations and Carnegie Hall. She has a screenplay and a TV show in the works, which she developed with her mentor and friend the late Arthur Herzog. She is a proud member of the Drama Desk and the Outer Critics Circle and was a nominator. Email: suzanna@t2conline.com

Film

Rope: Murder, Privilege, and the Art of Getting Away With It

Published

on

The New Group’s queer-forward revival of Patrick Hamilton’s thriller has a fascinating new perspective, a terrific ensemble, and one rather significant problem at its center.

Imagine The Boys in the Band with a murderous college classmate, a body in the living room, and a dinner party where the most dangerous thing on the menu is the truth. That is the deliciously sinister premise of Rope, Gordon Greenberg’s adaptation of Patrick Hamilton’s 1929 thriller, now receiving a provocative Off-Broadway production from The New Group at the Theater at St. Clement’s.

Cameron Monaghan, Corey Fogelmanis Photo credit: Monique Carboni

Alfred Hitchcock famously brought Rope to the screen in 1948, with James Stewart playing the professor whose intellectual theories become the justification for a horrifying crime. Greenberg moves the action to 1957, bringing the story’s once-sublimated homosexuality into the open while examining the equally treacherous territories of class, ethnicity, privilege, and the desperate need to belong. The question is whether this new interpretation can escape Hitchcock’s formidable shadow. The answer is yes and no.

Garrett Stern (Cameron Monaghan) and Nate Singer (Corey Fogelmanis) are brilliant, arrogant Princeton graduate students who have murdered a classmate and concealed his body inside a trunk in their fashionable Turtle Bay apartment. Rather than dispose of the evidence, they throw a dinner party, using the trunk as the centerpiece of their hospitality. It is an act of extraordinary arrogance, the ultimate demonstration of their belief that intellect and privilege place them beyond ordinary morality.

Garrett, who comes from modest circumstances, has learned to charm his way through Princeton society, carefully concealing the background that might compromise his standing among the privileged. Nate, born into money, has his own anxieties about belonging, particularly as a Jewish man navigating the social hierarchies of 1950s America. Their relationship is sexual, psychological, and profoundly unequal, with Garrett exercising a cruelty toward Nate that becomes one of the production’s most troubling elements.

Monaghan gives Garrett an icy assurance that makes his intellectual vanity genuinely disturbing. Fogelmanis captures Nate’s increasingly fragile composure, although the writing does him few favors. Garrett treats Nate so appallingly that one begins to wonder why Nate continues to participate in this grotesque experiment. Is the sex really that good? The production never provides a convincing answer. Sexual obsession can explain a great deal, but it cannot substitute for a fully developed psychological relationship.

Nate’s explanation that his nervousness comes from studying is another weakness. His agitation is so transparently connected to the murder that the excuse feels implausible. Suspense depends upon the possibility that a character might successfully conceal something. Here, Nate seems ready to confess before anyone has thought to accuse him.

Corey Fogelmanis, Elizabeth Gillies, Graham Phillips, Cameron Monaghan Photo credit: Monique Carboni

The dinner guests include Judge Kentley (James Waterston), the unsuspecting father of the murdered young man, and Professor Rupert Caddell (Jason Butler Harner), whose provocative intellectual philosophy has helped inspire his former students’ monstrous interpretation of human superiority. Harner assumes the role immortalized by Stewart, but approaches Rupert with his own intelligence and ambiguity. Nate’s friend Leila, played by Elizabeth Gillies, provides a welcome dose of sardonic wit, puncturing the room’s cultivated sophistication with a sharp eye for its absurdities.

Elizabeth Gillies, Graham Phillips Photo credit: Monique Carboni

The ensemble is excellent, finding layers of discomfort, vanity, and social calculation beneath the seemingly civilized conversation. The dialogue moves through sexuality, class, and ethnicity, while the audience remains acutely aware of the one subject nobody is supposed to discover: the body hidden only feet away.

Elizabeth Gillies, Graham Phillips, Jason Butler Harner Photo credit: Monique Carboni

One of Greenberg’s most effective departures from the familiar story is the use of flashbacks, which reveal Garrett, Nate, and Rupert’s histories while illuminating the private lives and motivations of the other characters. These sequences operate almost like the thought bubbles in a comic strip, allowing us to glimpse what lies beneath the polished surfaces and carefully constructed identities. They give the production psychological dimension beyond the mechanics of the murder mystery, suggesting that nearly everyone in the room is concealing something, even if only two have committed a crime.

Director Scott Elliott handles the material with assurance, balancing the drawing-room elegance with the increasingly uncomfortable knowledge of what lies beneath it. The production is at its strongest when social performance becomes indistinguishable from deception, and the audience is invited to examine how easily intelligence can be mistaken for moral superiority.

Derek McLane’s scenic design is deceptively simple but effective, establishing Nate’s inherited wealth without overwhelming the intimate theatrical space. Jeff Croiter’s atmospheric lighting is especially accomplished, giving the apartment a convincing, lived-in quality while allowing the storm outside to heighten the gathering sense of menace. The physical environment becomes an extension of the characters’ carefully maintained appearances: elegant, controlled, and increasingly threatened by what cannot remain hidden.


Jason Butler Harner, Corey Fogelmanis Photo credit: Monique Carboni

What makes this Rope interesting is its determination to examine the social structures beneath the crime. In Greenberg’s hands, murder becomes an expression of entitlement, a grotesque extension of the belief that certain people are exceptional enough to exist outside conventional rules. Garrett and Nate’s sexuality is no longer merely a coded suggestion, while their respective anxieties about class and Jewish identity deepen the portrait of a society obsessed with who belongs and who does not.

Yet making the subtext explicit creates its own challenge. Hitchcock understood the power of withholding information, allowing desire, suspicion, and moral corruption to circulate beneath the surface. Greenberg offers more explanation, more history, and more psychological exposure. Much of it is illuminating, but some of the mystery evaporates in the process.

Photo credit: Monique Carboni Photo credit: Monique Carboni

The result is a stylish, intelligent, occasionally uneven reimagining that succeeds more fully as a study of privilege and identity than as an exercise in sustained suspense. Its performers are compelling, Elliott’s direction is assured, and the production has enough provocative ideas to justify revisiting a familiar work. What remains elusive is a persuasive explanation for Nate’s devotion to a man who seems to regard him as little more than an instrument of his own superiority.

The trunk may contain the body, but the more disturbing question is what these young men have buried inside themselves.

Rope: The New Group, at the Theater at St. Clement’s, 423 West 46th Street, through December 20, 2026.

Continue Reading

Broadway

Theatre News: Bryan Cranston Returns to Broadway, Julia Roberts Finds Silence, Alec Baldwin Heads To The Tank, Hadestown Heads Home and John Kander at 100

Published

on

Broadway is preparing for a spring filled with star power, theatrical reinvention, and a celebration of one of musical theatre’s greatest composers. Bryan Cranston returns to Arthur Miller, Julia Roberts joins an extraordinary ensemble for a comedy in which almost nobody speaks, Hadestown brings its original Broadway stars into living rooms, and John Kander’s centennial promises an evening worthy of his extraordinary legacy.

Bryan Cranston and Marianne Jean-Baptiste Bring All My Sons to Broadway

Arthur Miller’s All My Sons returns to Broadway in an 80th-anniversary revival starring Bryan Cranston and Marianne Jean-Baptiste, following an Olivier Award-winning London engagement that concluded earlier this year. The limited Broadway run begins March 30, 2027, at the August Wilson Theatre, with opening night set for April 13.

Miller’s devastating examination of family loyalty, moral compromise, and the price of the American dream remains one of the playwright’s most unsettling works. Cranston, whose Broadway performances in All the Way and Network demonstrated his formidable command of the stage, returns to material that demands both emotional restraint and explosive confrontation. Jean-Baptiste brings an equally compelling dramatic intelligence to a play in which the past refuses to remain buried.

Eighty years after its premiere, All My Sons continues to ask a question that has lost none of its urgency: What happens when personal prosperity is purchased at the expense of collective responsibility?

Julia Roberts, Paul Rudd and Sarah Paulson

Julia Roberts, Paul Rudd, and Sarah Paulson Enter the Silence in Small Mouth Sounds

Julia Roberts returns to Broadway in Bess Wohl’s Small Mouth Sounds, beginning March 11, 2027, for a limited engagement scheduled through June. Joining her are Paul Rudd, Sarah Paulson, Martin Freeman, Greta Lee, and Isaac Powell, in an ensemble directed by Joe Mantello.

The acclaimed comedy follows six strangers attending a silent retreat, where nearly the entire story unfolds without dialogue. In an age when everyone seems determined to be heard, Wohl’s play finds humor, discomfort, and unexpected intimacy in what happens when language is taken away.

The production reunites Roberts and Rudd with Mantello, who directed them in Roberts’ 2006 Broadway debut, Three Days of Rain. That history adds another layer of interest to a production built around performers whose careers have been defined, in very different ways, by their ability to command attention. This time, much of the work will happen without a word.

The Original Broadway Stars of Hadestown Reunite on BroadwayHD

For those who missed the original Broadway company of Hadestown, December brings a particularly welcome opportunity. BroadwayHD becomes the exclusive United States streaming home of Hadestown: The Musical on Tuesday, December 1, with a virtual watch party beginning at 7 p.m. ET.

Filmed at London’s Lyric Theatre during several performances in 2025, the live capture reunites Reeve Carney, André De Shields, Amber Gray, Eva Noblezada, and Patrick Page alongside members of the West End company. The film, directed by Brett Sullivan, received a theatrical release in July 2026 and was reported by its producers to have set a box-office record for a live theatre capture.

Anaïs Mitchell’s extraordinary retelling of the Orpheus and Eurydice myth, directed for the stage by Rachel Chavkin, remains one of the most distinctive musicals of its generation. Its fusion of American folk music, New Orleans jazz, and ancient mythology earned eight Tony Awards in 2019, including Best Musical, as well as the Grammy Award for Best Musical Theater Album.

The production continues at Broadway’s Walter Kerr Theatre, while its international life has extended from London to Australia, South Korea, and Amsterdam. Its original Broadway cast recording has also reportedly surpassed one billion streams worldwide.

BroadwayHD is marking the premiere with a holiday promotion through December 11, offering new subscribers $50 off the first year of an annual subscription or a one-year gift subscription. Details are available at holidays.broadwayhd.com.

Alec Baldwin Takes on Horror: A Love Story at The Tank

Alec Baldwin stars in Horror: A Love Story, a new work by actor, filmmaker, and former Survivor contestant Jonathan Penner, at The Tank.

Described as a collision of TED Talk, family drama, and blood-soaked Grand Guignol, the production promises an unconventional theatrical experience that moves between intellectual provocation, personal storytelling, and the macabre. Penner’s combination of show-business experience and appetite for dramatic extremes suggests a work unlikely to remain comfortably within a single genre.

Photo by Jordan Hollender.

The Vineyard Theatre Celebrates John Kander at 100

Few composers have contributed more enduringly to the American musical theatre than John Kander, whose collaborations with lyricist Fred Ebb produced some of Broadway’s most recognizable and psychologically sophisticated scores.

On March 22, 2027, Vineyard Theatre will celebrate Kander’s 100th birthday with Kander’s 100th!, a one-night-only Broadway benefit honoring more than six decades of extraordinary musical achievement.

The evening is being created by Scott Ellis, Susan Stroman, and David Thompson, with performers from Broadway, film, television, and the music industry celebrating Kander’s remarkable catalogue.

From Cabaret and Chicago to Kiss of the Spider Woman and The Visit, Kander’s music has repeatedly demonstrated that entertainment and uncomfortable truths can coexist in the same unforgettable melody. His work can seduce an audience with theatrical glamour while quietly revealing the darkness beneath it.

A centennial tribute to John Kander is more than a birthday celebration. It is an opportunity to recognize a composer whose music helped define what the American musical could become.

Continue Reading

Off Broadway

The Curious Case of Benjamin Button: A Heartbreaking Reminder That Love Should See Beyond Appearances

Published

on

All my life, I have thought God got something terribly wrong. Why are we born young, only to grow old? Wouldn’t it make infinitely more sense to arrive in this world with the wisdom of age and gradually grow younger, shedding the burdens of time rather than accumulating them? It always seemed a rather wonderful arrangement. Then I saw The Curious Case of Benjamin Button at The Public Theater, and I realized something I had never considered. What happens when only one person lives that way, while the rest of the world regards him as a monster?

The cast photo by Joan Marcus

Based on F. Scott Fitzgerald’s 1922 short story, with book and lyrics by Jethro Compton and music and lyrics by Darren Clark, this extraordinary musical relocates the story to a small Cornish fishing village at the end of World War I. Compton, who also directs and designs the scenery, has created a theatrical world so complete, so inventive, and so emotionally devastating that its impossible premise becomes utterly believable. What begins as a curious fantasy becomes a profound examination of humanity’s inability to accept what it does not understand.

Andrew Durand and cast photo by Joan Marcus

Benjamin Button (Andrew Durand) enters the world as a fully formed 70-year-old man, dressed and already bearing the physical indignities of age. His mother (Sachiko Mae) is so horrified by what she has given birth to that she regards her own child with disgust, ultimately taking her life. His father (Brandon J. Ellis), consumed by shame, hides Benjamin away in the attic. Before Benjamin has had the opportunity to experience anything resembling childhood, he has already been condemned for the simple crime of being different.

This is where the story first broke my heart. What kind of world looks at a child and sees a monster? Benjamin has done nothing wrong. He has not chosen his appearance, his circumstances, or the extraordinary direction in which his life will unfold. He simply wants what every human being deserves: to be loved, to belong, and to experience life. Yet the very people entrusted with protecting him cannot see beyond what he looks like.

Eventually, Benjamin escapes the confines of his father’s home and discovers the local pub, where he meets Ebron (Claire-Frances Sullivan), a spirited young barmaid who becomes the great love of his life. Their connection is immediate, tender, and beautifully complicated. Their families oppose the relationship, and the lovers eventually separate, each setting out on a different journey while remaining bound to the other.

Benjamin goes to sea, where he befriends Jack (Morgan Morse), discovering friendship and adventure in a world that has offered him precious little of either. When Benjamin and Jack prepare to leave for war, fate brings Benjamin and Ebron together again. One night of love changes their lives, and eventually they become parents to Locryn (Kris Saint-Louis) and Elowen (Kelsee Kimmel).

For a time, Benjamin experiences the ordinary happiness that has always seemed beyond his reach. But time, which moves forward for everyone around him, continues to move backward for Benjamin. His body grows younger while his family grows older. Following an accident involving his daughter, Benjamin becomes desperate to find a cure for his condition. Unable to reveal the truth to Ebron, he leaves the woman he loves and his son, believing that somehow he can correct what nature has made of him.

It is a devastating decision, born not from a lack of love but from the conviction that he must change himself to deserve it. His search leads him back to Jack, whose reaction to Benjamin’s transformation is another cruel reminder of how quickly affection can disappear when confronted with something it cannot comprehend. Benjamin eventually returns, but this is not a fairy tale in which love conveniently conquers every obstacle. The consequences of time, separation, and fear cannot simply be undone.

Kelsee Kimmel and Andrew Durand photo by Joan Marcus

Durand is magnificent. His physical performance alone is remarkable, beginning with the stiffness, aches, and limitations of a septuagenarian and gradually transforming into the restless energy and awkward innocence of youth. Yet his achievement extends far beyond an impressive technical exercise. He gives Benjamin an emotional transparency that makes his loneliness almost unbearable. There is something especially moving about watching a man whose body becomes increasingly young while his experiences grow increasingly old. Durand captures the sweetness of first love, the exhilaration of discovery, and the terrible realization that the world may never allow him to live an ordinary life.


Kelsee Kimmel is equally compelling as Elowen, providing the emotional center around which Benjamin’s extraordinary existence revolves. Their relationship possesses a lyrical beauty that transcends the unusual circumstances of his birth. She is the sea, and he is the moon, two forces forever connected, drawn toward one another even when separated by distances neither can control. Benjamin dreams of walking on the moon, and during his lifetime he witnesses humanity accomplish that seemingly impossible feat. The symbolism is exquisite. Mankind can conquer the heavens, yet still struggle to accept the person standing directly in front of us.

Darren Clark’s score is glorious, drawing upon the musical traditions of Cornwall with Celtic influences, folk rhythms, and melodies that seem to emerge from the sea itself. At times, the harmonies possess the haunting beauty of sirens calling across the water. At others, the music bursts with the irrepressible energy of a village celebration. The entire ensemble doubles as the orchestra, playing violins, guitars, accordion, cornet, cello, and drums while singing and inhabiting multiple characters. Their musicianship is astonishing, and the music never feels like accompaniment. It is the lifeblood of the production.

Chi-San Howard’s choreography is equally inspired. The performers move with such instinctive rhythmic precision that their bodies seem to become additional instruments. Every gesture, turn, and movement contributes to the storytelling. Under Mark Aspinall’s musical direction, the company functions as a beautifully calibrated ensemble, creating an atmosphere in which music, movement, and narrative become inseparable.

Compton’s scenic design is deceptively simple and extraordinarily effective. A large wooden dock and layered staircases establish the village’s maritime world, while fishing nets and buoys suspended above the stage create the impression of a place shaped by generations of sailors, fishermen, and storytellers. Throughout the evening, one feels transported to an old Cornish pub, listening to the extraordinary tales of people who have spent their lives at the mercy of the sea. The difference is that these stories unfold directly before us, as though memory itself has taken physical form.

Anna Kelsey’s costumes are beautifully conceived, allowing the performers to move effortlessly between narration and characterization through remarkably efficient changes. Zoe Spurr’s lighting is especially inventive, transforming the stage from the warmth of a village gathering to the dangerous mystery of the open water. Her work becomes particularly mesmerizing during the sequences in which Benjamin appears to drown, moments when light, movement, and theatrical illusion combine to breathtaking effect. Luke Swaffield’s sound design preserves the intimacy of the storytelling while allowing the music to surround us. Like most shows today sometimes they lyrics are lost.

The supporting company deserves enormous recognition. Sachiko Mae and Brandon J. Ellis establish the emotional cruelty of Benjamin’s beginnings, while Morgan Morse gives Jack a humanity that makes his eventual rejection all the more painful. Kris Saint-Louis and Claire-Frances Sullivan bring tenderness to the family Benjamin struggles to preserve. Matt Wolpe, Katie Horner, Trevor Lindley Craft, and Britney Coleman contribute to an ensemble whose versatility is nothing short of extraordinary. These are not simply performers who happen to play instruments. They are consummate theatrical storytellers whose collective talent creates an entire community before our eyes.

Beneath the humor, exuberance, and extraordinary musical invention lies a story about time and tides, both of which move according to laws that human beings cannot control. There is mythology here, certainly, but also an uncomfortable truth about the human condition. We claim to celebrate individuality, yet so often punish anyone whose existence challenges our expectations. We admire difference when it entertains us, but recoil when it asks us to reconsider our understanding of what is normal.

Benjamin’s tragedy is not that he ages backward. It is that the people around him cannot accept him as he is. His life is filled with extraordinary experiences, yet so much of his happiness is stolen by shame, rejection, and the desperate belief that he must somehow become like everyone else. He spends precious years searching for a cure to a condition that is only monstrous because others have decided to see it that way.


What makes The Curious Case of Benjamin Button so affecting is that it never loses its humanity amid the fantasy. It is funny, exuberant, inventive, and filled with remarkable music, but its emotional power comes from a deceptively simple question: Why is it so difficult for us to love someone without demanding that they conform to our expectations?

I entered the theatre believing that Benjamin Button’s backward journey through life might be a wonderful gift. I left understanding that no gift, however extraordinary, can protect someone from a world determined to misunderstand him.

We have learned to send human beings into space, to cross oceans, and to accomplish things once considered impossible. Benjamin lives long enough to witness a man walk on the moon, the very dream that once seemed beyond his reach. Yet the greatest journey humanity has still to make may be the one that takes us beyond appearances, prejudice, and fear.

The Curious Case of Benjamin Button, playing at The Public Theater through December 6, is a breathtaking theatrical achievement and a profoundly moving reminder that love should never depend upon looking like everyone else.

One small step for mankind would be learning to see beyond what someone looks like and recognize the human being within.

Continue Reading

Off Broadway

Ms. Blakk for President: All That Glitter Is Not Political Gold

Published

on

The night before I saw Ms. Blakk for President at the Vineyard Theatre, my friend George asked me whether America was ready for a transgender president. My answer was no. After seeing Tarell Alvin McCraney and Tina Landau’s new musical, my answer was an emphatic no, although not for the reasons one might expect. The problem isn’t the audacity of Joan Jett Blakk’s candidacy. It’s that the musical seems far more interested in having a good time than examining what that candidacy actually meant. At a moment when political spectacle has become almost indistinguishable from political substance, another evening of glitter, slogans, and self-promotion hardly feels revolutionary.

Joan Jett Blakk, the drag persona of Terence Alan Smith, launched a presidential campaign in 1992, during the devastating AIDS crisis, with a slogan that remains deliciously provocative: “If there are so many bad actors in politics, why shouldn’t the president be a good drag queen?” It is a terrific line, and one that exposes the theatricality of American politics with admirable precision. Unfortunately, Ms. Blakk for President never quite develops the intelligence behind that observation into a compelling theatrical argument.

Co-written by McCraney and director Landau, the jukebox musical follows Smith’s transformation into Joan Jett Blakk and the campaign that eventually brings her to the 1992 Democratic National Convention at Madison Square Garden. The premise is irresistible. Here was a Black drag performer challenging a political establishment that had spent years failing the gay community while AIDS claimed lives at a horrifying rate. Satire, anger, grief, and political courage were all available to the playwrights. Instead, the show too often settles for camp, spectacle, and the assumption that being outrageous is the same thing as being meaningful.

Ato Blankson-Wood Photo by Carol Rosegg

Fortunately, Ato Blankson-Wood is fabulous. Dressed in screaming pink Chanel-inspired finery with black accents, ropes of pearls, and a blonde bob that suggests a Black Jackie Kennedy, he commands attention from the moment he appears. Ari Fulton’s costumes are a delight, filled with witty details that understand the difference between dressing a character and creating an icon. Blankson-Wood delivers his lines as though every syllable has been dipped in glitter, finding humor and warmth even when the writing gives him little beyond another opportunity to charm.

As Blakk, he talks his way through confrontations with police, wins over an initially indifferent non-voter, and deflects a security guard with a combination of audacity and irresistible theatrical instinct. These are the moments when the production comes alive, revealing the charisma that made Joan Jett Blakk more than a novelty. Blankson-Wood understands that a drag queen’s greatest weapon is often the ability to expose the absurdity of those who take their own authority too seriously.

Yet charisma cannot substitute for character development. We are repeatedly told that Smith possesses wit, warmth, and a commitment to his community, but the musical rarely allows those qualities to evolve into a coherent political purpose. By the time Blakk reaches the Democratic convention, even the blonde wig has disappeared, and so, it seems, have some of the promises made to Queer Nation. The transformation should carry emotional or political weight. Instead, it raises questions the show seems unwilling to answer.

Ato Blankson-Wood , Gideon Glick Photo by Carol Rosegg

Gideon Glick brings welcome urgency to Mark, a Queer Nation activist whose partner is dying of AIDS. Unlike the increasingly self-absorbed theatricality surrounding Blakk, Mark has a concrete reason to fight. He understands that a drag performer running for office could attract attention to a crisis that the political establishment would prefer to ignore. His strategy is not necessarily to win, but to lose loudly enough that America can no longer pretend not to hear.

That is a fascinating proposition. Political defeat can become a form of victory when it forces an uncomfortable truth into public consciousness. Yet the musical never fully reconciles Mark’s activism with Blakk’s appetite for the spotlight. Is Joan using celebrity to advance a cause, or is the cause becoming another vehicle for Joan’s celebrity? The distinction is central to the story, and the production dances around it rather than confronting it.

Adina Verson and Sawyer Smith Photo by Carol Rosegg

The supporting ensemble is considerably more disciplined than the material. Nic Ashe, Kelvin Moon Loh, Sawyer Smith, and Adina Verson are wonderfully versatile, moving among drag performers, activists, journalists, police officers, and assorted personalities who populate this politically charged world. They bring energy, comic precision, and considerable talent to a production that demands constant reinvention. Their commitment is never in question, even when the musical’s direction is.

David Zinn’s scenic design consists of interlocking runways resembling pieces of Lego’s. The performers dart across these fragmented platforms, creating the impression of a political and cultural landscape that refuses to fit neatly together. Boxy Philips televisions surround the playing space, displaying Rasean Davonté Johnson’s carefully assembled projections of 1990s footage. The imagery effectively evokes the era’s media saturation, when television shaped public perception and political performance increasingly became entertainment.

Bradley King’s lighting, however, is another matter. Its aggressive intensity repeatedly overwhelmed both me and my guest, at times making the production genuinely difficult to watch. There is a difference between creating the atmosphere of a nightclub and assaulting the audience with illumination. A production about visibility should not leave its spectators struggling to see.

The jukebox score compounds the show’s structural problems. Fleetwood Mac’s “Don’t Stop,” David Bowie’s “Starman,” and Janis Joplin’s “Piece of My Heart” are among the familiar selections pressed into service. Individually, these songs have undeniable appeal, and their placement within a drag-show framework provides opportunities for energetic performance. Collectively, however, they do little to advance the dramatic argument. Rather than deepening the characters or sharpening the political commentary, the music frequently interrupts the narrative, leaving the evening feeling like a series of entertaining numbers searching for a reason to coexist.

There are genuinely compelling ideas buried beneath all this theatrical excess. American politics has always contained an element of performance, and a drag queen campaigning for president exposes that hypocrisy with particular elegance. The question of representation is equally important. Does visibility constitute progress when it produces no meaningful change? Can a public figure claim to speak for a marginalized community while placing personal ambition ahead of collective responsibility? And when thousands are dying, is attracting attention enough, or must that attention lead somewhere?

Adina Verson, Gideon Glick, Nic Ashe, Ato Blankson-Wood and Sawyer Smith Photo by Carol Rosegg

These are questions Ms. Blakk for President should be asking with greater force. Instead, McCraney and Landau’s script often feels like we are in the Twilight Zone of the previous century, collecting its fashions, music, slogans, and political imagery without finding a sufficiently compelling dramatic through line. The AIDS crisis provides the historical urgency, but the musical’s relentless pursuit of fun repeatedly undercuts that urgency.

What makes this especially frustrating is that Joan Jett Blakk’s actual candidacy deserves serious theatrical consideration. Humor can be a formidable political weapon, and drag has a long history of confronting authority by making its pretensions ridiculous. There is nothing inherently frivolous about using laughter to expose injustice. The problem arises when the laughter becomes the destination rather than the means of getting somewhere more consequential.

Blankson-Wood gives the evening its sparkle, Glick supplies much of its emotional conscience, and the ensemble works tirelessly to keep the proceedings moving. Yet Ms. Blakk for President remains a musical in search of its own identity. It wants to be a political satire, a drag extravaganza, a historical reckoning, and a celebration of queer defiance. Those ambitions are not incompatible, but they require a stronger script and a clearer understanding of what the evening ultimately wants to say.

The show needs more than a makeover. It needs to decide whether Joan Jett Blakk was running for president to illuminate a national tragedy or simply to stand in the spotlight. Until it answers that question, all the glitter in the world cannot disguise the absence of a compelling political heart.

Ms. Blakk for President: Vineyard Theatre, 108 East 15th, through November 29th.

Continue Reading

Off Broadway

The Steel Man: When the Sins of the Father Become the Burden of the Son

Published

on

The Holocaust left scars that extended far beyond those who survived it. Its horrors were carried into marriages, homes, and the lives of children born long after the war ended. In Cary Gitter’s The Steel Man, now playing at 59E59 Theaters through December 13, that inheritance becomes the foundation of a volatile father-son relationship. The trouble is that while the play asks us to understand the damage inflicted by history, it never quite makes us care enough about the man inflicting damage of his own.

Sam Guncler and Leighton Samuels Photo Credit: Carol Rosegg

Originally given its world premiere at Penguin Rep Theatre in Stony Point, New York, The Steel Man is set in Pittsburgh in 1983. At its center is Leo Gellert (Sam Guncler), a 70-year-old Hungarian Jewish immigrant and Holocaust survivor whose wife died a year earlier. His son Jake (Leighton Samuels), 29, has spent his life living beneath the weight of his father’s anger, cruelty, and unresolved trauma. Leo escaped the Nazis, but he has never escaped the past. Unfortunately, neither has his son.

Sam Guncler and Leighton Samuels Photo Credit: Carol Rosegg

Leo is not simply a difficult father. He is an abusive one, a man who bullied his wife and has spent decades belittling Jake. His grief and survivor’s guilt have hardened into a bitterness that poisons everyone around him. The play wants us to consider the psychological devastation of surviving the unimaginable, but trauma does not automatically confer sympathy, particularly when its victim becomes the tormentor of another generation.

Samuels gives a painfully convincing performance as a grown man who remains emotionally trapped in childhood. Jake has been so thoroughly diminished by his father that confrontation seems almost beyond his capabilities. When Leo dismisses him as weak, Jake responds, “I’m not weak. I’m broken.” It is one of the play’s most revealing lines, exposing the difference between a man who lacks courage and one whose courage has been systematically dismantled.

Leighton Samuels, Amanda Kristin Nichols, Sam Guncler Photo Credit: Carol Rosegg

Jake has an opportunity to escape. He has received a full scholarship to study acting at Juilliard, while his girlfriend Christine, known as Chris (Amanda Kristin Nichols), has secured a journalism position at The Village Voice. New York represents a future free of Leo’s suffocating presence. Yet Jake cannot bring himself to tell his father that they are leaving, postponing the inevitable confrontation while allowing his anxiety to dictate every decision.

Leighton Samuels, Amanda Kristin Nichols, Sam Guncler Photo Credit: Carol Rosegg

Nichols brings welcome strength and independence to Chris, a woman who understands what she wants and refuses to be defined by Leo’s prejudices. When she offers to help light the Shabbat candles, Leo dismisses her as a “shiksa,” turning what should be a gesture of warmth into another opportunity for hostility. Nichols makes it clear that Chris will not quietly absorb the insults Jake has spent a lifetime accepting. Her self-possession provides a necessary contrast to his paralysis.

Amanda Kristin Nichols, Leighton Samuels Photo Credit: Carol Rosegg

Yet Jake’s avoidance becomes a dramatic problem. Samuels makes his suffering believable, but the character’s inability to act grows frustrating. We understand why he is damaged; we are less persuaded by his continued surrender. There comes a point when sympathy begins to give way to impatience, and The Steel Man does not entirely overcome that obstacle.

Guncler’s Leo is even more difficult to embrace. He prowls through the production with the ferocity of a wounded animal, his fury barely contained and his cruelty frequently unchecked. There is little tenderness to balance his rage, little evidence of the complicated love that might make this relationship truly devastating. A father can be monstrous and still reveal flashes of humanity. Here, those flashes are too scarce to illuminate the man beneath the monster.

Leo’s obsession with the past eventually takes the story beyond the confines of the family home. During the war, members of his family were sent to Auschwitz after being betrayed to the Nazis by Zoltan Bako, a village policeman and family friend. Forty years later, Leo has discovered that Bako is living in Miami. Armed with a gun and information obtained through a private detective, he becomes determined to exact revenge.

This should be the moment when the play’s moral complexities deepen. What does justice mean four decades after an atrocity? Can revenge restore anything that was stolen? What happens when a man who survived evil allows his life to be governed by it? These are substantial questions, but Gitter’s script does not explore them with the depth they deserve. Instead, the narrative moves toward an emotional resolution that feels more engineered than earned.

The final gesture belongs to Jake, who discovers a way to return something precious to his father: images of Leo’s former life in Hungary, preserved in a film shot on the family’s farm before the world he knew was destroyed. It is an imaginative and potentially moving act of filial love, offering Leo a glimpse of himself before grief, betrayal, and hatred consumed him.

The idea is lovely. The execution is less satisfying. After witnessing so much cruelty, we are asked to accept the possibility of reconciliation without having been given sufficient emotional groundwork to believe in it. Jake’s compassion is admirable, but compassion alone cannot resolve a lifetime of abuse. The ending reaches for catharsis before the play has earned its release.

Joe Brancato directs with a sure understanding of the material’s claustrophobia, keeping the performances taut and the emotional temperature high. The production’s most striking achievement, however, is visual.

Christopher and Justin Swader’s scenic design transforms the Gellert home into a kind of elevated shoebox, its fourth wall removed so that the audience can peer directly into this family’s private misery. The familiar furnishings of a 1980s living room are framed by a sharply defined enclosure, with the foyer and front door visible beyond. The effect is both voyeuristic and suffocating. We are watching people who occupy the same house but remain imprisoned in entirely different emotional worlds. For Jake, the walls seem to close in even when the door is standing open.

Christian Fleming’s costumes reinforce the period without calling attention to themselves, while Ed McCarthy’s lighting and Max Silverman’s original music and sound design sustain the production’s uneasy atmosphere. Brian Pacelli’s projections are particularly effective in supporting the play’s exploration of memory, where the past remains more vivid to Leo than the present.

At approximately 85 minutes without an intermission, The Steel Man is economical in length, though not always in its emotional repetitions. Gitter has an important subject, and the generational consequences of the Holocaust deserve thoughtful dramatic examination. But the play struggles with a fundamental question: how do we reconcile compassion for a survivor with accountability for the suffering he has inflicted on those closest to him?

The answer cannot simply be that Jake must forgive his father because his father endured unimaginable horrors. Leo’s suffering explains much of his behavior, but it does not excuse it. Nor should Jake’s ability to show kindness be mistaken for evidence that the damage has been repaired.

The Steel Man contains compelling performances, an inventive production design, and the foundation of a far more penetrating drama. What it lacks is the emotional complexity that would allow its central relationship to transcend cruelty and obligation. Brancato directs the material with conviction, but Gitter’s script and particularly its ending need further refinement.

Ultimately, the most haunting question is not whether Leo can find peace with his past, but whether Jake can finally find a life that belongs to him. That is the story I wanted The Steel Man to tell more fully.

The Steel Man: Penguin Rep Theatre at 59E59 Theaters through December 13th.

Continue Reading
Advertisement

Trending

Copyright © 2023 Times Square Chronicles

Times Square Chronicles