Off Broadway

Vatican Falls Opens Off Broadway At The Tank

Vatican Falls Opens Off Broadway At The Tank

There have been at least 330,000 cases of sexual abuse of children by Catholic priests, nuns, Popes and others in the church. The number will really never be known due to the Church officials covering them up and many men still in shame over crimes that were not of their own choosing. The abused, mostly boys, but also girls, start as young as three years old, with the majority of abuse between the ages of 11 and 14. Cases have also been brought against members of the Catholic hierarchy, who then covered up the sex abuse allegations and moved abusive priests to other parishes, where the abuse always continued. This is a world wide pandemic.

Edward L. Simon, Ace Young Photos by Ashley Garrett

I personally knew the brave and courageous Phil Saviano, the man who helped bring down almost 250 priests in Boston and more. One priest can have over 3,000 victims and most of the time they are kept silent.

James Gracia, Edward L. Simon Photos by Ashley Garrett

I am a survivor of sexual abuse, so plays of this nature have me wanting to cheer, sadly Frank J. Avella’s Vatican Falls, has great intent, but is missing so much.

This two and half hour long play is confusing, all over the map, miscast, misdirected and missing character development. It felt like a new playwrights work. Maybe the author and director Mr. Avella, is too close to the work, for the play tells real survivor’s stories. The show is co-directed by Carlotta Brentan, who is also in the show playing the love interest. Never a good idea, as you need non bias eyes.

Jeremy Clapp, Danny Hilt Photos by Ashley Garrett

I hate writing this review, as most who survive sexual assault are damaged, with some ending their lives as a result of victimization and disbelief by those they love. I wish to offer only love and support for victims, but sometimes being a reviewer puts us in horrible places.

Vatican Falls, takes place non-linear, so the audience is never sure if they are in Boston, Rome, New York or Los Angeles. The play also spans decades, and we are never sure which one we are in. The show would be better starting from the beginning and moving forward in time, with flashbacks.

Carlotta Brentan, Ace Young Photos by Ashley Garrett

In the course of all this is a love story between a Vatican operative Claudia (Brentan) and our protagonist Riccardo (American Idol heartthrob Ace Young). On Riccardo’s side are fellowship leader, Vi (Tucker Aust), whose desire for retribution fuels what seems like a survival group. In the group are the homosexual Matt (Jeremy Clapp), the straight Charlie (Danny Hilt) and their spy Gianluca (Jacopo Constantini), who turns out to be abused and related to Claudia.

Tucker Aust, Ace Young Photos by Ashley Garrett

As we learn about Riccardo’s life, we meet his alcoholic mother (Alice Barrett Mitchell), His younger brother Peter (James Gracia) and the priest who abused both boys and manipulated the mother Father David (Edward L. Simon).

Ace Young, Alice Barrett Mitchell, James Gracia Photos by Ashley Garrett

There is also a Monsignor (Ryan Wright), who we are not sure if he abused, but he is defiantly covering it up.

One of the most confusing things and the image that stays in your mind, is when Peter takes off his shirt and he is covered in hickeys, bruises or something else. The priest who is abusing him wants him to be on the swim team, yet these would show. We are never told what these are or how others would not see this and question. Also in the end who was abused first and who is the older and who is the younger brother come into question.

The show is unevenly cast and in the end, all of the actors and the playwright’s resumes read better than what was on that stage.

Vatican Falls: The Tank, 312 W 36th Street, through November 20th.

Off Broadway

Suzanna, co-owns and publishes the newspaper Times Square Chronicles or T2C. At one point a working actress, she has performed in numerous productions in film, TV, cabaret, opera and theatre. She has performed at The New Orleans Jazz festival, The United Nations and Carnegie Hall. She has a screenplay and a TV show in the works, which she developed with her mentor and friend the late Arthur Herzog. She is a proud member of the Drama Desk and the Outer Critics Circle and was a nominator. Email:

More in Off Broadway

Ensemble Studio Theatre Announces New Co-Artistic Directors

Suzanna BowlingFebruary 2, 2023

Theatre News: MJ, Teachers Night on Broadway, The Actors Studio, Ragtime and The Wiz

Suzanna BowlingFebruary 1, 2023

The McKittrick Hotel Announces The Return Of The Drama Desk Award Winning Production Of The Strange Undoing of Prudencia Hart

Suzanna BowlingJanuary 29, 2023

Anthony Rapp’s Without You Is a Touching Remembrance on Death and Rent

Suzanna BowlingJanuary 27, 2023

Submissions For Short New Play Festival Open

Suzanna BowlingJanuary 27, 2023

NYTW’s Merrily We Roll Along Triumphs in Reverse, Wonderfully

RossJanuary 25, 2023

The Outer Critics Circle Announces Dates and New Category Distinctions for the 72nd Annual Outer Critics Circle Awards

Suzanna BowlingJanuary 25, 2023
Adrienne Warren

Theatre News: Room, Camelot, Between Riverside and Crazy, Bedlam and Hip Hop Cinderella

Suzanna BowlingJanuary 24, 2023

The York Theatre Company to Present One-Night Only Spring Benefit Concert “Julie Sings Jule”

Suzanna BowlingJanuary 24, 2023